My parents purchased a Jeep to tow behind their mobile home. I can't remember if it was a Liberty, Compass, or Patriot. They like it for the specific purpose it serves.
When I asked my dad's opinion of his Jeep, he told me I needed to seriously consider it. At that time the CR-V was the only real option. When I started reading about the Renegade, I test drove one. I was sold on the TrailHawk. While test driving the CR-V I put my foot in the fuel tank to see what it could do. It yawned at me. The drive was adequete, but boring. I was going to have a boring drive every day to work...
In comparison the TrailHawk jumped when I put my foot in it. Now, don't get me wrong, it didn't break traction, but the Jeep made it clear that we were going to go somewhere. The steering was COMPLETELY different. I felt like I was driving... a rally car? Responsive. The drive was far from boring. In fact I looked forward to getting behind the wheel again, and I hated driving.
Now, back to topic...
No, I have no interest in a Wrangler. If I wanted one, I would have bought one. What I wanted was a small CUV, 4WD, off road capability, MPG, and... fun. I live in Colorado. I drive a 1000 miles a week. I wanted a balance. Only the Renegade provided it. So no, I won't be "stepping up" to the Wrangler. If this vehicle continues to perform as admirably as it has, I'll be buying lots of Renegades. Probably, one every three to four years.
And my purchase of the Renegade may have been driven (PUNishment) by one of the Jeeps that people loathe...
BTW, I'm so sick of "welp, it's not a Wrangler, so is it a REAL Jeep?" I tell you what. Get your Juke, CX-5, CR-V, and whatever Toyota has, and follow me on the trail. One that makes it to the end... is a Jeep.