I turned 60 this year (on the outside), but am still in my early 20's on the inside, and the Renegade is tops on my short list (a distant second on the list is the Subaru CrossTrek Hybrid!).
Waiting for the Renegade to be available for touching, driving, listening. My wife and I both want something quiet (so no all terrain treads), comfortable inside, about 30 mpg or so at hiway speeds (ie - 70mph and above), room for luggage (selling the house, already downsized our 'stuff' nicely - getting ready to do some long term travel to the ocean, any ocean), and $30k nicely fitted (ie - leather, safety stuff, electronic stuff, etc).
I want all wheel drive for those moments when safety or forward progress calls for it. I have my 97 Wrangler for real off-road thrills, so don't need mega-off road capabilities in this vehicle.
My gut is telling me the Renegade is going to be the vehicle for us, over the CrossTrek.